Doc Searls Provides a new ‘Clue’ for the Identity World

Payments Views

September 24, 2007

by Linda Elliott
The exhibition floor at a conference can tell you a lot about the state of development of the topic. Exhibitors front and center on the exhibit floor at Digital ID World this week are MSFT, Novell, Oracle, AOL, while the smaller players, who were the only ones a few years ago: Ping, Radiant, Securent are there, but not as prominent. Many of the original companies in this space have been acquired by the powerhouses of IT infrastructure.


Is this show old news? Well Digital Identity has hit mainstream…the early adopters (Mike Beach at Boeing for example) are attending the conference to track the nuances of where identity has gone…such as how to best define ‘roles’ for users and tie that to their identities so that permissions are granted appropriately.

Identity is now woven into the fabric of systems management and security…its part of the infrastructure. This isn’t to say that there isn’t a lot going on, but the need to define authentication requirements for corporate assets in data and applications is taken for granted. The FFIEC Strong Authentication for Internet Banking forced the tipping point for mainstream deployments. Federations are used for commercial communities, like GM and their suppliers, Boeing and their customer airlines, GSA and their contractor community, and health care networks that include clinics, hospitals, doctors, and drug companies.

Will there ever be a large-scale third party identity provider that consumers use?… the digital equivalent of their drivers’ licenses? The problem with that, as Mike Beach points out, is that each application has its own requirements for identity ‘assurance’ and attributes, and its really difficult for any community to accept another community’s authentication. For non-sensitive applications, which are not risky from a fiduciary or information steward point of view, the identity assurance of Facebook may be enough.

But as Doc Searls, one of the authors of the Cluetrain Manifesto, points out in a new ‘clue’ : private ‘social networks’ do not make a marketplace. A real market is about ‘transactions’. For economic markets where more assurance is required, liability still looms as the great inhibitor. Don’t look for broad third-party authentication services in areas with compliance or financial risk anytime soon.

The Glenbrook team is comprised of talented professionals from all areas of the payments industry, including business management, marketing, technology, operations, risk management, and business analysis. They have held senior roles at central banks, international banks, card networks, merchants, fintech startups, payments processors, and more. Together, Glenbrook Partners has become known as the go-to source for problem-solving, insights, and learning. Our team of bright minds and critical thinkers is what makes it possible.

Through our education wing, we have educated over 35,000 payments professionals on topics ranging from B2B payments to digital currencies and policy and regulation. Our experienced consultants have helped organizations in 62 countries achieve their goals with strategy advisory, in-depth research, and more. In addition to supporting payment professionals, the Glenbrook team is a valuable resource on the top issues of the day, sharing their experience and insights with professionals eager to understand industry fundamentals and how they are evolving.

Payments News

Stay on top of the rapidly evolving payments world with Glenbrook’s free curated news feed, delivered daily to your inbox.

Payments Views

Read our commentary and opinion blog written by members of the Glenbrook team on payments industry topics, large and small.

Glenbrook’s live and on-demand workshops help you understand and apply the innovations shaping the payments industry. Register today or schedule a custom workshop for your team.

Launch, improve & grow your payments business