From time to time, one of us at Glenbrook will take a deeper look at a particular issue or opportunity facing the payments industry. Below you'll find the archive of these occasional writings. As always, we .
One of the "hot topics" in payments in the US market is the evolution of mobile payments - from "inevitable idea" to reality. Obopay and PayPal Mobile are both now over 2 years old - having been launched in the spring of 2006. TextPayMe, a mobile payment service that launched in late 2005, is now a part of Amazon's payments offerings. How are these services evolving? » More
by Bryan Derman
We were intrigued by this week’s announcement that the FDIC had issued enforcement actions against two banks (and reached a settlement with a third bank) related to their sponsorship of credit card programs promoted by CompuCredit.
» MoreI’ve just returned from the Chicago Federal Reserve Banks’ 2008 Payments Conference where this year’s topic was Payments Fraud: Perception versus Reality. The conference had good presentations on fraud perspectives in payments ranging from check processing to PayPal, mobile commerce, and contactless card technology. » More
Glenbrook's Allen Weinberg and Jim Salters attended this week's Payments 2008 conference in Las Vegas. Here's Jim's report about the expedited bill payment opportunity for banks. » More
Glenbrook's Allen Weinberg and Jim Salters are attending this week's Payments 2008 conference in Las Vegas. Here's Allen's second report from today's sessions including his notes on the panel he chaired this afternoon titled “Payments aren’t about Payments Anymore”. » More
After years of working in the somewhat arcane arena of digital identity and authentication, I’ve found my attention to what’s going on slipping somewhat. » More
Glenbrook's Allen Weinberg and Jim Salters are attending this week's Payments 2008 conference in Las Vegas. Here's Jim's report on the day one general session. » More
Glenbrook's Allen Weinberg and Jim Salters are attending this week's Payments 2008 conference in Las Vegas. Here's Allen's first report from today's sessions. » More
This year’s annual ETA seemed bigger than in previous years, and from almost everyone that I spoke to, much more exhausting. In my humble opinion, this was the first year that had a really compelling set of sessions to choose from. Unfortunately, I and quite a few others were never able to make it to many or even any of the sessions. Chalk it up to many more exhibitors to talk to, and the presence of many more old friends and colleagues to catch up with! » More
Glenbrook, in cooperation with Forte Financial just finished our first Payments Workshop on B2B payments, called "eB2B Payments at the Tipping Point". » More
I spoke last week with Elliott McEntee, President and CEO of NACHA about two current issues - NACHA's reaction to "de-coupled debits" and the progress of the Secure Vault Payments program. » More
On a New York visit over the last several days, I used four taxis - and paid with my debit card each time. (New York City has recently implemented a regulation requiring all cabs to accept card payments - without minimums or added fees.)
As I paid, I asked each driver whether or not card payments were good for drivers. I got two vehement "no's", with bitter remarks about the 5% fee they pay. I got one equally emphatic "yes", with the added comment that tips were much better on airport runs. And I got one perfect New York "whatever.." with matching shrug. » More
As you seek to find that special gift for that special someone this year, why not take a different approach? Recently, we've been working with several non-profit payments providers and discovered new payment services -- and new ways to pay -- that can help you find a unique gift and make a positive impact.
» MoremFoundry recently announced a new round of financing with a line-up of strategic investors including Motorola Ventures, PayPal, NCR, and a "leading wireless operator" - along with their existing investors. In their announcement, the company described its business as "a comprehensive and equitable solution for financial institutions, wireless operators and other mobile banking and payment providers". This begs a question: Will balance across the players bring the most compelling solution to market, or will one of the constituents beat the others? » More
One of the reasons I went to the AFP (Association for Finance Professionals) conference in Boston in October 2007 was to get updated on the progress of the migration of business to business (B2B) payments from checks to electronics.
As a general statement, progress on this has been very slow. But recent acquisitions (Xign by JPMorgan Chase, Harbor by Amex) and product announcements (most recently, the MasterCard Payment Gateway) seemed to signal a change in pace.
So off to Boston I went, asking myself the question: Are there developments that will change the pace of conversion to electronics? My answer is “yes” – read on! » More
Here's an update on NACHA topics from this morning's sessions at the Association for Financial Processionals conference being held this week in Boston. » More
There are 6,000 people at this year's AFP (Association of Finance Professionals) conference in Boston, and it feels like half of them must be smashed into this morning's session on "The Retail Merchant's Customers' Payment Options: Deciding Between C21, BOC, ARC & POP". » More
I'm in London this week for meetings with clients. Here's an "up close and personal" field report on my first real London shopping experience - payment card in hand - at Harrods. » More
Linda provides another update from this week's Digital ID World.
Phil Becker asked the question at a Digital ID World breakout session:
“What will make Amazon or eBay start really using the identity infrastructure?”Those who watch the web, authentication initiatives following on the FFIEC push for strong authentication dating back two years now, and identity have wondered about this for a long time. There is a notion that a third party authentication provider could emerge and provide identity authentication for many sorts of applications. But it hasn’t happened yet. Why not? » More
I completely agree with this thumbnail mobile banking strategy. But let's refine it a little into the 10-step cookbook version. » More
We get asked a lot about our views about mobile banking and payments. Mobile payment is a whole separate kettle of fish - and not something I'll address here. But mobile banking is here and now as most major banks are making their decisions about how to offer mobile banking this year. » More
There has been a lot of attention paid to identity authentication in the payments world over the last several years. Five years ago, systematizing the use and sharing of identity beyond the proprietary structures of vendor products was a new idea and there was great energy in the marketplace. The Liberty Alliance attracted large financial associations as well as movers and shakers in the financial world. Inevitably, open source and open standards groups weighed in with innovative approaches. » More
I recently took a look at the eBay Q2 2007 10-Q SEC filing to get some more details on the PayPal growth story. Read on for the details. » More
In the US market, the furniture group IKEA is putting payment choices into action at its stores. Encouraging debit usage is the latest step in steamlining checkout practices and reducing payment acceptance costs.
Ikea's new Debit Card Advantage 1% coupon encourages consumers to pull out their debit card at the point of sale.
“Use your debit card at IKEA and you will automatically receive a coupon worth 1% of your total purchase. This coupon is valid at your next visit to IKEA and does not expire”Furniture store tickets are not generally thought of as small ticket / cash replacement merchants - the more traditional role for debit. Ikea's strategy reflects an overall consumer trend to increased debit card usage.
Demonstrating their active management of consumer payment choices, IKEA was an early mover in stopping the acceptance of personal checks (see “Retailer’s role in the demise of check”). Ikea continues to offer favorable payment terms for purchases over $1000 with 12 months free interest.
Glenbrook's Carol Coye Benson is back from this week's Payments 2007 conference sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. The theme of this year's conference was "Competitive Forces Shaping the Payments Environment: What's Next?." Click here to read Carol's full conference report on Payments News.
With roughly 4 1/2 months remaining before year-end, we thought we'd share our take on some of the recent industry developments and our lessons learned as we've helped our clients prepare for the deadline.
» MoreGlenbrook has been following Peppercoin since 2002 and has closely monitored the company’s strategy and progress. We were pleased by Peppercoin’s shift in direction two years ago—and we continue to be impressed by its ability to listen to the market, adjust its strategy, and move forward with a payment service that we believe to be unique in the industry.
» MoreWith online payment fraud now entering its second decade, recent fraud studies are somewhat encouraging and show that the percentage of revenue lost by eCommerce merchants to online fraud is declining. But these same studies also underscore that with the steady growth of online commerce and digital goods and services, the actual sales revenue lost to payment fraud continues to increase year over year. The eCommerce paradox is that while online payment fraud is dropping in relative terms, it is growing in absolute terms. And with eCommerce merchants expected to lose as much as $2.8 billion to payment fraud in 2005, according to the 2006 CyberSource Annual Fraud Report, the problem is demanding greater management attention, the development of industry best practices, and the pursuit of new solutions.
» MoreSome thoughts from Bryan on reading leading indicators in Consumer Financial Services.
» MoreIn his recent keynote address at the Direct Response Forum (DRF) conference in San Francisco, Glenbrook’s Allen Weinberg explored the payments acceptance landscape, how it relates to card-not-present merchants, and offered his assessment on what it may mean.
» MorePeppercoin 2.0 extends the notion of transaction aggregation into both the physical world of small point-of-sale payments as well as across multiple merchants. Through this new “universal aggregation” capability, Peppercoin plans to aggregate individual consumer purchases at multiple merchants into a single card transaction. By doing this aggregation, the per-transaction fees that would otherwise be paid on each purchase are reduced—with the resulting savings shared between Peppercoin and merchants participating in the Peppercoin network. This research note analyzes how Peppercoin 2.0 actually works, explores its new value proposition, and offers an initial assessment of its potential strengths and weaknesses.
» MoreReflections on the PayPal/GE Consumer Finance Alliance
On June 8th, 2004, PayPal quietly announced it was partnering with GE Capital Consumer Card Company to begin offering credit lines to customers that want extended payment terms for any PayPal purchase. PayPal’s business members started receiving direct mail pieces the following day offering new credit lines up to $50,000.
» MoreWhen President Bush signed the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003 (FACTA) into law late last year, bankers throughout the U.S. breathed a sigh of relief. Even with some fairly stringent new provisions, the permanent renewal of the FCRA’s preemption provisions -- which curtail the ability of consumer-friendly state law to override provisions of the federal legislation -- was good news for banking.
» MorePhishing has emerged as the latest threat to the theft of personal information over the Internet. This Glenbrook ActionMap(SM) briefing for financial institutions examines the phishing threat, provides brief technology background on how fraudsters are successfully perpetrating phishing frauds, and recommends an ActionMap for institutions to consider for responding effectively to these threats.
» MorePundits believe that RFID tagspositioned as a next-generation replacement for the familiar bar codeare going to drive vast improvements in the efficiency of supply chains as products wind their way from the manufacturers out to the retail shelves. Critics believe that RFID tags pose a significant threat to personal privacy, in that tags worn or carried by individuals permit unwanted surveillance by anyone with an RFID reader. They contend that RFID technology and its use in business should be heavily regulated, if not outright banned for specific applications. The court of public opinion is still listening to both sides of the debate.
» MoreAs enterprises implement new identity management systems, interest grows in federated identity. For small "circles of trust," existing business relationshipsand existing contractual frameworksare sufficient to build federated networks. But with eyes everywhere cast on the opportunity to create larger circles of trust, what business frameworks will be needed to support these large-scale federated networks?
» MoreMomentum towards stronger financial privacy for consumers in the United States has picked up a lot of steam over the last 30 days. While most welcome the change, some financial institutions are still tentative about the new direction, others are actively resisting it, and a few are not sure how to respond. But to strategic thinking institutions wanting to secure competitive advantage, we believe that now is the time to actgetting out in front of the financial privacy issue, leveraging their reputations for trust, and better serving their customers in the process.
» MoreI recently attended the O'Reilly Emerging Technologies Conference hoping to learn about up and coming technologies that might hold promise for Glenbrook's clients. While I didn't find exactly what I was looking for (the opportunities in financial services for smart dust, robofly, and nanotechnologies continue to elude me) I did have one of those "Eureka!" moments when I understood how effectively the big three Internet applicationsAmazon, Google, and eBayhave morphed into open service platforms. What is happening here on a broad scale should be instructive for many financial services providers and eCommerce providers.
» MoreI've been playing with the new Apple iTunes Music Store with my Mac OS X iBookincluding buying some new (actually, old) music! In addition to rediscovering some favorite songs, I'm also exploring how Apple has tackled the micropayments problem using old-fashioned credit cards.
» MoreHow the Liberty Alliance and related digital identity protocols may solve the identity theft crisis.
» MoreIdentity theftthe fraudulent use of private personal data and financial credentialsis getting a lot of attention these days. Consumers are concerned and legislators are on the march proposing various regulatory solutions. Since most of the damage is done prior to detection, we argue that it is critical to get consumers involved as early as possible. Consumers are more eager to help than the financial services industry might think.
» MoreMicropaymentsthose pay-per-click, penny-level transactionsare back in the news. Red Herring magazine recently published an article (1) entitled "Micropayment's Big Potential" that paints a pretty rosy picture about several up and coming micropayment systems.
» MoreThere's a sea change happening in the world of digital identity. Suddenly, crypto-geeks and impassioned aficionados of biometrics, software tokens, and smart cards are being pushed to the side. The suits have arrived! Digital identity is no longer about security; it's now a marketing conversation.
» MoreIn a recent critique of the Liberty Alliance entitled "On Liberty and the Case for Anonymous Federation of Identity," (1) Doug Kaye raises several critical points about the Liberty 1.0 specifications:
» MoreLike everyone else in the digital identity world, I have spent the last few days reading through the version 1.0 specifications from the Liberty Alliance. Overall, hats off! Alliance members have done an outstanding job of creating a framework for shared authentication and identity. We can (and will) argue with elements of the designwith its over-complication of simple processes and the over-simplification of complex issues. But the Alliance has commendably tackled most of the issues, and importantly not shied away from the hard problems or vulnerabilities. This has neatly set the stage for early adopters to get to work.
» More